Best of: Pies

Who doesn’t love a good slice of delicious, homemade pie every once in a while?

If you don’t feel like spending all day in the kitchen trying to master the perfect pie, several places in Jackson offer sweet and savory pies that will satisfy any pie craving. Here are some of our favorite places to pick up the tasty treat.

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop’s I-40

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop – 1220 East Northside Drive
Scott and Meredith Layton opened Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop just a few years ago, and they take pride in their family’s recipes and traditional baking methods that they use in their pie shop.

With classic and specialty flavors, Buttermilk Sky Pie is the perfect place to grab a pie or three for any event, gathering, or just for yourself.

Try flavors like Southern Custard (Buttermilk), Granny’s Apple, Chocolate Cream, Key Lime, Peanut Butter Cream, Coconut Cream, Chewy Chocolate Chip and the I-40, which includes pecans, chocolate chips and a sprinkle of toasted coconut in a pecan pie filling. Seasonal flavors also rotate and Spiced Pumpkin is available right now in the spirit of fall.

Pies are available in full-size, 9-inch pies that serve up to nine people, 4-inch pies that are great for personal indulgence or gifts and 2-inch pies. buttermilkskypie.com/menu/

Urban Foxes’ Peanut Butter pie

Urban Foxes826 North State Street
Belhaven’s newest sweet shop is serving up baked goods, coffee and craft beer, and, of course, sweet and savory pies.

The small-batch bakery is owned by Jackson native Cody Cox, who formerly served as the general manager at Cups’ Fondren location. He and his co-owner (and spouse), Molly West, prepare freshly baked pies and other sweet treats daily.

Flavors of pie rotate: check their social media for daily offerings. Slice O’ Pies are $5. And flavors can range anywhere from Pecan to Peanut Butter to Lemon Ice Box, Peanut Butter Baby Ruth, Coconut Cream, Apple Custard or Blueberry Rhubarb. urbanfoxesjxn.com/menu-page

Geraldine and Esma’s Seven Layers of Sin pie

Geraldine and Esma’s Kitchen1492 Canton Mart Road, Suite 1
The same folks who brought you Crazy Cat Eat Up now have a second endeavor, Geraldine and Esma’s Kitchen (in the former Cookin’ Up a Storm space).

The authentic Southern cuisine includes casseroles, meatloaf, and other goodie and that includes pies. On any given day, you can find flavors like Blueberry Pie, Three Tomato Pie, Milky Way Pie, Buttermilk Pie and Seven Layers of Sin Pie – graham cracker crust, coconut, butterscotch, chocolate chips, toffee, pecans and sweetened condensed milk.

Share this Story

Paige McKay

eat. drink. MISSISSIPPI is a food magazine dedicated to sharing Mississippi's passion for food with the world. From local chefs making their culinary mark to the many great restaurants this state has to offer, Mississippi's hospitality shines through in the pages of this magazine. It is our desire to preserve our culinary heritage and inspire today's cooks with a new passion for cooking and eating. All opinions expressed in this post are the opinions of the writer and not necessarily those of Sipp Jackson.

Leave a Comment